Grain Country Again Expecting
Railroad, Storage Congestion
WASHINGTON (AP) Wheat fills Kansas
elevators and is piling up on the ground. The corn
harvest is just around the corner and expected to be the
second-biggest ever. Rail car delivery is backlogged.
"We're bracing ourselves," said Linda
Donovan, co-manager of the Norton County Co-Op in
northwest Kansas.
Sound familiar? In farm country, the memory of the
congestion that choked shipping throughout the West is
only too near.
But this is not the rail crisis of 1997, when gridlock
driven by Union Pacific Corp.'s takeover of Southern
Pacific Rail Corp. stranded Midwestern grain crops,
clogged California ports and forced the temporary idling
of some Gulf Coast petrochemical plants, with an economic
toll estimated as high as $4 billion.
The biggest difference is that in many cases, the
grain has nowhere to go. Abundant global supplies and
sagging exports to financially troubled Asia have beaten
down already-low prices, forcing farmers to stockpile
back-to-back, bumper wheat harvests. The storage shortage
appears worst in Kansas and parts of Iowa, Minnesota and
Oklahoma.
"The point is, if we moved every car that we had
to market, there isn't a market for all of it. That's the
problem," Union Pacific Railroad spokesman Ed
Trandahl said.
Union Pacific, the nation's largest railroad, was
under orders to cooperate with competitors from last Oct.
31 until federal regulators ruled last month they could
no longer force UP to keep giving business to other rail
carriers. Most agree that while service has not returned
to normal, the emergency is over.
"Even if the railroads perform most admirably,
there still will be grain on the ground this year,"
said Bill Brennan of the U.S. Department of Agriculture's
transportation and marketing division. "Major export
markets are shut down in the midst of a huge economic
crisis right now."
Price and lack of export markets are factors, concedes
Rep. Jerry Moran, who is in the home stretch of a tour
through the 66 counties he represents in western Kansas.
"But every elevator operator tells me he or she
has a place to go with the grain, if they could just get
the railroads to move it," said Moran, a Republican.
"We continue to get calls from shippers saying they
can't get any cars."
Kansas as of last Tuesday recorded 430,200 wheat
bushels on the ground or in temporary storage. The state
agriculture department said the number may soar to
anywhere from 75 million to 100 million, more than triple
the 31 million bushels Kansas farmers dumped last year.
Corn growers in neighboring Missouri are apprehensive
too.
"We have almost no confidence that the railroads
are going to be able to provide the type of service that
we've had in the past," said Gary Marshall,
executive director of the Missouri Corn Growers
Association. "With more wheat already in bins, we
think it's going to force more grain into the market
pool."
Moran, who serves on the railroad subcommittee of the
House Transportation Committee, is among a handful of
lawmakers who have proposed legislation designed to
minimize the chance of another meltdown. Trouble is,
Congress plays a peripheral role.
"What it comes down to is the ability of the
railroad to operate properly," said Tom White, a
spokesman for the Association of American Railroads.
"It's hard to see what legislation can do about
that."
Congress is not likely to act this year on related
legislation, said Moran, who sponsored a measure nudging
the federal Surface Transportation Board to make the
industry more competitive. Competition has been a
rallying cry of shippers and some lawmakers, who blame
the STB along with the railroads for okaying the
mega-merger in the first place and for refusing
last month to extend the emergency remedies.
Moran wants Surface Transportation Board Chairwoman
Linda Morgan to visit the Wheat State to see the railroad
woes firsthand. "The lack of rail service could be
devastating for the Kansas farmer," Moran wrote in
an Aug. 25 letter to Morgan. "The STB needs to see
the situation in Kansas."
Union Pacific Railroad has a backlog of a few hundred
rail cars, while car delivery from Burlington Northern
and Santa Fe Railway Co. is several days behind. But the
railroads offer evidence that service has improved.
BNSF had loaded 26,895 grain cars in Kansas through
last July, spokesman Jim Sabourin said, compared to
43,989 through July of this year. "Just the fact
that we are keeping up with demand and handling more
grain tells you that there's some improvement
there," Sabourin said from company headquarters in
Fort Worth.
Trandahl, a UP spokesman at the railroad's
headquarters in Omaha, Neb., said the railroad should be
running smoothly by next month.
"We are a few hundred cars backlogged, which is a
big improvement over the first half of August, and we
think that by mid-September, we basically will not have
any backlog," Trandahl said.
The railroad's cycle time for grain cars has improved
slightly less than 1 percent over July
1997, Trandahl said. He noted one train recently traveled
from Kansas to Arizona and back in just over seven days,
"and that's on a line where we've had some
congestion."
Meanwhile, at the Norton, Kan., co-op, grain isn't yet
piled on the ground and shipping has been regular,
Donovan said. But she plans to have to pile grain on the
ground this fall at another location.
"We're not into harvest yet," she said.
|