Rancher Finally Gets Court
Appearance After Seven YearsRENO, Nev.
(AP) Seven years after he filed his lawsuit,
Tonopah rancher Wayne Hage finally got a chance in court
to argue why the federal government should pay $28.4
million for his ranch in Monitor Valley.
Hage told U.S. Claims Court Judge Loren Allen Smith
last Thursday that he had to sell part of his ranch
because of the cost of the protracted litigation. The
government has sought dismissal of the lawsuit since it
was filed in September 1991.
The trial is expected to last two weeks, though Judge
Smith may not make his decision before early next year.
Before the trial, Hage estimated his legal expenses so
far have been $1.2 million to $1.5 million.
"It's a simple land adjudication case,"
cracked Hage, author of "Storm Over
Rangelands," a book published in 1989 in which he
argues ranchers have private property interests in the
public lands.
In a case that challenges the federal government's
authority to manage public lands, Hage, 61, maintains
that old state and federal laws dating back to 1866 gave
ranchers control over lands in the West long before the
national forests were created and federal grazing laws
were passed.
Philosophical leader of the Sagebrush Rebellion, Hage
sued the U.S. Forest Service in 1991 after rangers
confiscated and sold 108 head of his cattle. He had been
charged with repeated grazing law violations when his
cattle were confiscated.
At the time, Hage operated the 759,000-acre Pine Creek
ranch in Nye County. All but 7000 acres were lands
managed by the Forest Service and the Bureau of Land
Management. Hage held grazing allotments on the public
lands.
In the lawsuit, Hage charges the Forest Service had
repeatedly harassed him for more than decade, starting in
1978 when he rejected the agency's offer to buy his ranch
for half of what he paid for it. He said "relentless
attacks" by the agency forced him to sell 2000 head
of cattle and left him without a livelihood.
He also maintained that he was targeted by the Forest
Service after he wrote his book critical of federal
grazing practices.
Hage wants $4.4 million for taking his ranch, $2
million for cattle losses, $12 million for water rights
and $10 million in damages.
|