EU Hedging On Compliance With
Ruling Against Hormone BanLUXEMBOURG
(AP) The European Union Commission said
Monday it will not be able to offer definitive scientific
justification for a ban on imports of hormone-treated
beef within the deadline set by the World Trade
Organization.
But the EU's executive branch said that it still hoped
to keep U.S. hormone-treated beef out by collecting
enough preliminary scientific evidence by the May 13,
1999 target date.
The 15-nation EU has to meet that deadline to comply
with a WTO ruling on its 1989 ban on imports of
hormone-treated beef, EU officials said.
The EU launched new studies after the WTO
acting on complaints by the United States and Canada
ruled last year that the scientific basis of the
EU ban on imports of hormone-treated beef was not sound
enough.
EU Farm Commissioner Franz Fischler told a regular
meeting of EU farm ministers that some of the results of
the new studies into the risks to human health posed by
cattle growth hormones would not be available until 2000,
the officials said.
He said most of the results would be ready in 1999,
but not necessarily before next May 13, they added.
Nonetheless, Fischler said the Commission hopes to use
preliminary evidence from the studies to justify the ban
by the WTO compliance deadline, the officials said.
The remarks by Fischler came four and a half months
after the WTO ordered the Commission to comply by next
May 13 to its ruling that the EU hormone-treated beef
import ban is illegal.
In response, the Commission said it would seek
compliance by changing the scientific justification for
the ban rather than by lifting it. To that end, it
ordered in February eight independent studies into the
risks posed by six cattle growth hormones.
The EU import ban came after a 1988 ban on the use in
the EU of growth hormones in beef. The ban is based on
contentions that the hormones can cause cancer.
The U.S. cattle industry has said the EU import ban is
costing it $250 million a year in sales.
|